The Basics of Betting the NBA Playoffs

When I was young and dumb, I used to argue with my friends that playoff basketball couldn’t actually be that different from the regular season. My argument would usually go something like: “These players are making millions of dollars a year and are playing to make millions more. How could they not be trying their hardest in the first place?” Again — I was young and dumb. Looking back, my argument was completely wrong. Anyone with eyeballs can see that the NBA playoffs are completely different from the regular season when it comes to effort, strategy, and overall gameplay.

This creates opportunities in betting, but it also increases the risk. I’ve talked before on Kirk’s Hammer about having a perceived edge, but missing one key piece of info and accidentally donating for months while thinking you’re just running bad. This becomes especially true if you’ve been betting the NBA regular season but don’t really understand the key intricacies of playoff basketball. Today, I’m going to run through what I consider some of the most important changes from the regular season to the playoffs.

Zig-Zag Theory

I think this is the clearest example of if you don’t know about it, you’re completely screwed betting NBA playoff spreads. Zig-zag theory at its most basic is simple: if a team loses a game, it becomes more likely they win the next one. I’m calling it a "theory" here, but it’s obvious the market believes in it. Look at some game 1 and 2 prices from teams that lost game ones this playoffs:

• LAC Game 1: +3 → Game 2 LAC Pick'em

• LAL Game 1: -4.25 → Game 2: LAL -5.5

• HOU Game 1: -1.5 → Game 2: HOU -4

All these teams lost Game 1 and got way better prices for Game 2. However, it’s not automatic — for example, OKC won Game 1 by 50 and still got a better price for Game 2. The Knicks got roughly the same price after winning their Game 1. There are a lot of intricacies to when and how much zig-zag theory matters, and if you’re serious about betting NBA playoffs, you should study it pretty substantially.

As for why zig-zag exists, it’s hard to pinpoint exactly, but logically a few things are obvious: if you’re down 2–0 in a series, you’re more likely to increase your best players minutes, players are more likely to go max effort, coaches more likely to implement any adjustments they were waiting to use. Desperation matters.

Rotations

When I’m betting props in the regular season, I’m usually looking for a wide range of angles. In the playoffs, though, it’s almost entirely a minute’s game. Stars play way more, and rotations shrink — usually down to 8–9 players early on, and sometimes as tight as 7–8 later in the playoffs.

During the regular season, rotations are typically very set: Player X checks in with 5 minutes left in the first quarter, checks out with 7 minutes left in the second, and so on. Sure, players' minutes can move around depending on how they’re playing, but those shifts usually happen slowlyApp. In the playoffs, it’s a totally different story. It’s a best-of-seven series — no time to waste — and coaches adjust fast. That creates massive right and left tails in minute distributions, opening up big prop betting opportunities.

In the regular season, a starter isn’t randomly going to play 8 or 40 minutes — it’s just not how it works. In the playoffs, it’s more common. Some coaches are aggressive with adjustments, others are stubborn, so knowing each coach’s tendencies — and how comfortable they are with a given player — is critical.

Coaching Strategy

In the regular season, one of my biggest pet peeves is seeing people post on Twitter something like: “Tatum under 27.5 points -110, Team X is really going to try to get the ball out of his hands and they have a great defender for him.” I hate this because regular season NBA teams rarely dramatically change their defensive scheme for one opposing player.

It makes sense — it’s one game out of 82, often with one night between games and constant travel. Teams are way more focused on running their system properly than adjusting because they happen to be playing a superstar on a Tuesday in March. That’s not to say teams never adjust — but it’s much rarer than people on gambling Twitter seem to think.

In the playoffs, though, that completely flips. Teams are playing the same opponent over and over in a best-of-seven series. Adjustments are everything. Coaches might decide "we need to force Player X to his left hand," or "we’ll live with him taking above-the-break threes but not corner threes." Understanding what a team is trying to take away — and what they’re willing to live with — can create massive prop betting edges.

This also has a huge impact in the totals market. If you’ve been following this year’s playoffs, you’ve seen massive game-to-game swings in totals. Houston vs. Golden State Game 1 closed at 213; by Game 3, the total is down to 202.5 — a massive adjustment after just two games. Being able to understand why a game went over or under, and how pace or shot quality might change moving forward, can be a huge edge for betting playoff totals.

Statistical Changes

With all these adjustments, it’s no surprise that the actual stats shift dramatically too. Pace and scoring typically fall off hard — especially in recent years where regular season scoring has exploded.

In 2023, the average total points in a regular season game was 229.4; in the playoffs, it dropped to 219.2.
In 2024, regular season games averaged 228.4 points; in the playoffs, it’s down to 211.2.

That’s a huge drop. And it’s not just points — assists, rebounds, steals, and blocks all shift noticeably in the playoffs. If you’re betting props, you need to be adjusting player rate stats heavily based on playoff conditions.

Final Thoughts

Overall, I love betting the NBA playoffs. The regular season is much more mechanical — "I make this total 231, it opens 228, I take the over." Playoff betting is much more about ball knowledge — trying to figure out what actually happened in a game and how it could impact the next one. It’s fun and can offer massive edges, but it’s also way more challenging.

🟡🐕 Sign up to Underdog and deposit using code CIRCLES to receive up to $1K in bonus cash + a gimme pick or simply click this link: https://play.underdogfantasy. (https://play.underdogfantasy.com/p-circles-off)com/p-circles-off (https://play.underdogfantasy.com/p-circles-off)

🔵⚪️ New to FanDuel Sportsbook? Bet $5 and Get $200 in Bonus Bets if your bet wins. Download the FanDuel Sportsbook App or check it out at http://fanduel.com/forwardprogress to get in on the action.

Must be 21+ and present in select states or 18+ and present in DC. Opt in req. Bonus issued as non-withdrawable profit boost tokens. Restrictions apply, including any token expiration and max wager amount. See terms at sportsbook.fanduel.com. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit rg-help.com.

⚽️ The world’s biggest sport. Your next big edge. Soccer is coming to Betstamp PRO — with global leagues and player props, it’s the odds screen trusted by pros to uncover inefficiencies and scale profit.

Newsletter readers get exclusive early access: betstamp.com/circlesoff (http://betstamp.com/circlesoff)

🔵🟡 Get yourself an Edge Boost Visa Debit to eliminate the headaches of deposits and for cash back on your betting: https://www.edgeboost.bet/guide/?oid=196&affid=117